| # | WRESTLER | REGNO | DATA | LOCATION | EVENTO | NOTE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | Tommaso Ciampa | 1 | 25/07/18 | Winter Park, FL | NXT | |
| 15 | Aleister Black | 1 | 07/04/18 | New Orleans, LA | NXT Takeover: New Orleans | |
| 14 | Andrade Almas | 1 | 18/11/17 | Houston, TX | NXT Takeover: WarGames | |
| 13 | Drew McIntyre | 1 | 19/08/17 | Brooklyn, NY | NXT Takeover: Brooklyn III | |
| 12 | Bobby Roode | 1 | 28/01/17 | San Antonio, TX | NXT TakeOver: San Antonio | |
| 11 | Shinsuke Nakamura | 2 | 03/12/16 | Osaka, Japan | NXT Live event | |
| 10 | Samoa Joe | 2 | 19/11/16 | Toronto, Canada | NXT Takeover: Toronto | |
| 9 | Shinsuke Nakamura | 1 | 20/08/16 | Brooklyn, NY | NXT Takeover: Brooklyn II | |
| 8 | Samoa Joe | 1 | 21/04/16 | Lowell, MA | NXT Live event | |
| 7 | Finn Bálor | 1 | 04/07/15 | Tokyo, Japan | The Beast in the East | |
| 6 | Kevin Owens | 1 | 11/02/15 | Winter Park, FL | NXT Takeover: Rival | |
| 5 | Sami Zayn | 1 | 11/12/14 | Winter Park, FL | NXT Takeover: R Evolution | |
| 4 | Adrian Neville | 1 | 27/02/14 | Winter Park, FL | NXT Arrival | |
| 3 | Bo Dallas | 1 | 12/06/13 | Winter Park, FL | NXT | |
| 2 | Big E Langston | 1 | 09/01/13 | Winter Park, FL | NXT | |
| 1 | Seth Rollins | 1 | 29/08/12 | Winter Park, FL | NXT | (1) |
